Teen murder charge shows ‘gaps’ in Malaysia’s treatment of girls | Women’s Rights News

Teen murder charge shows ‘gaps’ in Malaysia’s treatment of girls | Women’s Rights News

In February, a 15-year-previous girl was charged with killing her newborn right after giving start by itself in a home in the jap Malaysian condition of Terengganu.

The infant was located to have accidents on its human body, including what appeared to be a stab wound. When the law enforcement arrested the woman, she instructed them she experienced been raped by a man in his twenties. A 7 days afterwards, she was charged with murder.

The intimately harrowing character of the case shocked many in Malaysia and when once more introduced general public awareness to the country’s higher rate of teenager pregnancies and relevant difficulties – which includes restrictive reproductive legislation, statutory rape and youngster relationship.

Lots of authorities were anxious about the managing of the teenager’s case.

“I see the gaps in the technique, the require to physical exercise a punitive approach with minimal regard for the ideal interest of the kid,” Hartini Zainudin, a baby rights activist, instructed Al Jazeera. “Nothing is youngster-centred.”

Infanticide and baby abandonment are not unheard of in Malaysia – a multi-ethnic and mainly conservative nation, in which 61 p.c of the population is Muslim.

In excess of the past five years, the Ministry of Overall health has recorded 41,083 pregnancies among adolescents.

The Ministry of Girls, Family members, and Community Progress experienced also previously noted that about 830 expecting youngsters obtain services at govt health and fitness facilities every single month.

This kind of situations led to much more than 1,000 circumstances of little one abandonment and infanticide involving 2010 and May possibly 2019, the ministry also beforehand reported.

‘A ton of failures’

In the girl’s circumstance, it was uncovered by the Human Legal rights Commission of Malaysia (SUHAKAM) that her household had been unaware she was expecting, as she had not been at residence and had dropped out of college since she was not able to accessibility on the net mastering when pandemic-linked lockdowns shut her faculty.

“There are a great deal of failures in devices in supporting her wellbeing during, which includes during her pregnancy,” claimed Alyssa Wan Azhar, a social employee at Women’s Aid Organisation, an NGO campaigning versus gender-primarily based violence.

Young women gather outside Malaysia's parliament with banners calling for an end to child marriage. One placard showing a stick man marrying a young girl says 'child marriage is child abuse'
Activists have been contacting for an conclusion to boy or girl relationship for several years, but the federal government mentioned just lately it would not ban the practice [File: Ahmad Yusni/EPA]

Youthful ladies in Malaysia are typically pressured to toe the line in a conservative and patriarchal society, wherever sexual intercourse education is also lacking. Abortion on the grounds of rape, or even incest, is also banned unless a health care provider deems that the pregnancy is a threat to the mother’s bodily or mental wellbeing.

If their daughter becomes pregnant, some dad and mom see relationship as the ideal way to steer clear of household shame, even if she is just a child and even though intercourse with a minimal is deemed statutory rape.

“We take care of a whole lot of instances exactly where a kid will get raped and is then pressured into relationship. Culturally, it is found as a answer. But it just further more traumatises the survivor simply because she is now stuck with the perpetrator for a life time,” Alyssa Wan Azhar explained.

In accordance to UNICEF, there ended up 14,999 conditions of kid marriage in Malaysia involving 2007 and 2017 across all communities, with 10,000 of them involving Muslims. In 2018, 1,856 young children – 1,542 of them Muslim – were married. The report outlined little one marriage as where at the very least a person of the get-togethers was under 18.

Even with phone calls to ban kid marriage, the Malaysian govt not too long ago announced that it would not do so, indicating it chosen to address the problem by employing community schooling and socioeconomic programmes.

Malaysia has a twin legal program, with civil and Islamic laws operating aspect by side. Instances involving Muslim family members and relationship troubles appear under Islamic law, which is the duty of the country’s particular person states.

That means that whilst the minimum age for relationship is established at 18 and the age of consent is 16, Muslim marriages drop under the states’ purview – and they enable marriage underneath the bare minimum age providing the Islamic courtroom approves.

“Unfortunately, in Malaysia, youngster marriage has been utilised as a way out for perpetrators hoping to avoid prosecution by marrying their victims,” in accordance to a 2020 UNICEF report on baby relationship in the place.

To reduce incidences of toddler abandonment, the authorities has operate intercourse training campaigns focusing on sexual abstinence outside relationship, and introduced baby hatches the place mothers can anonymously depart their babies. There are also distinctive colleges so young adults who are expecting can continue their schooling.

Salmi Razali, head of Universiti Teknologi MARA’s psychiatry section, experienced beforehand interviewed 9 imprisoned girls – just one of them a teenager – convicted of filicide (killing a son or daughter) in Malaysia. In a paper released in 2018, she claimed that they had not found the initiatives useful.

“It may well be mainly because these products and services are directed at changing ladies and gals and not their social context,” she wrote.

Young Malaysian girls including Muslim Malays, ethnic Indians and Chinese sit in a school hall in their uniforms
Malaysia’s population is the vast majority Malay Muslim but there are also sizeable communities of ethnic Chinese and Indians [File: Bazuki Muhammad/Reuters]

Hartini states the strategy has to modify.

“We exercising our cultural beliefs and biases, inform kids and younger folks not to do this or that, but don’t give them adequate info and help to know much better, and punish them when they fall short to comply with our societal beliefs and values,” she explained. “Why haven’t we learnt from the very last higher-profile case in point?”

The finest interests of the kid

The lady, meanwhile, remains in custody, remanded by a magistrate on February 9 even though she was still getting put up-natal therapy in medical center. The subsequent day, she was discharged and transferred to a law enforcement station ahead of a court docket physical appearance a 7 days later, where she was charged with murder.

The criminal offense carries the death penalty in Malaysia, but below-18s who are identified guilty are jailed for a interval decided by the king.

In a general public assertion, Noor Aziah Mohd Awal, SUHAKAM’s Children’s Commissioner, stated that the woman should have been specified “proper postpartum procedure such as psychological treatment” prior to being prosecuted, and assigned a social welfare officer to safeguard her during the legal method.

Noor Aziah informed Al Jazeera that the police typically do not avail by themselves enough of the Youngster Act, which seeks to far better guard little ones who come into conflict with the law.

“When a little one is arrested, this has usually happened: the child is detained in a law enforcement station and spends the night time in law enforcement lockup. The police will dilemma them without the need of informing their parents or the social welfare officers, and there is no authorized illustration,” she explained.

The girl only attained legal representation when a few attorneys stepped in to symbolize her immediately after reading through media experiences about the case, while Hartini crowdfunded money for her bail application.

AG Kalidas, president of the Malaysian Bar Council, highlighted in a public statement that the National Authorized Assist Foundation has the energy to deliver totally free authorized help to any child in conflict with the law from the minute of arrest or detention – if only the law enforcement and the courts would make the child and their mother and father informed of it. Even so, as Noor Aziah and Hartini position out, there is a shortage of professional lawyers taking on lawful support circumstances, since the get the job done is mainly voluntary.

Azalina Othman Mentioned, chairman of the Parliamentary Specific Pick Committee on Females and Children’s Affairs, and Social Growth, has advised a charge of infanticide would be more proper in the teenager’s situation, since it concerned “the killing of a newborn by its mom within just 24 several hours of its birth”.


The Penal Code stipulates that a female could be billed with infanticide if at the time of the criminal offense, “she experienced not totally recovered from the influence of offering birth” and “the stability of her mind was then disturbed”. The offence carries a optimum jail time period of 20 years.

Continue to, the demand of murder continues to be. And in spite of her lawyers’ arguments – that she is under the age of 16, a lady, and unwell immediately after only recently giving delivery (which are achievable grounds for an exception under non-bailable offences these as murder and infanticide) – her software for bail on February 15 was turned down devoid of reason, and rejected once more on appeal three months later.

Rather, she was granted a psychiatric analysis at a govt medical center by the Kuala Terengganu Higher Courtroom. Underneath Malaysian regulation, a court have to refer an accused for psychiatric analysis if it suspects they may possibly be of unsound mind.

Her legal professionals have reapplied for bail, but the teen remains in law enforcement detention awaiting demo.

The Lawyer General’s Chambers has due to the fact revealed a assertion indicating the cost could be reviewed pending more developments – together with the effects of the investigation into the girl’s rape allegation.

Even so, the alleged perpetrator, who has been identified by police and requested to change himself in to aid investigations, remains at large.